asqh.org

I Tried Catholic Health Insurance. Here’s My Real Take.

Written by

in

Quick outline:

  • What I mean by “Catholic health insurance”
  • My two real experiences (a health share, and an employer plan)
  • The good, the tough, and the odd little things
  • Who this works for (and who it doesn’t)
  • Simple tips that saved me money and stress
  • Final verdict

Wait—what counts as “Catholic” here?

Here’s the thing. People say “Catholic health insurance,” but it can mean two different things:

  • A Catholic health sharing ministry (not insurance). Think Solidarity HealthShare (for comprehensive membership details and up-to-date guidelines, see the official Solidarity HealthShare website).
  • An employer health plan at a Catholic place. Mine was through Christian Brothers Services (they publish plan specifics and member resources on the Christian Brothers Services site).

I’ve used both. Same faith vibe. Very different day to day. For an even wider look at faith-based health care models, the resources at ASQH are worth bookmarking. Their writer also tried a broader Christian option and shared an honest take on health insurance for Christians.

Story One: My family with a Catholic health share (Solidarity HealthShare)

We used Solidarity for two years. It’s a health share, not insurance. Members “share” bills that follow Church teaching. So no abortion, no birth control, no IVF. Natural family planning (NFP) is welcome. That part mattered to us.

What we paid and how it worked

  • Our family monthly share was a little under $500.
  • We had an “Annual Unshared Amount” (like a deductible). Ours was $1,500 per person.
  • We paid the first bills up to that amount. After that, the community shared most eligible costs.

I kept a little spreadsheet. Nothing fancy. Date, doctor, amount. It helped a lot.

Real-life bills they shared for us

  • Maternity: Our second baby, healthy delivery. Hospital billed about $13,000. Solidarity re-priced it down a lot, then shared the rest after our AUA. We set up a payment plan with the hospital while we waited. It took months, not weeks. That part was stressful. I kept snacks in the car for those calls.
  • Prenatal labs and ultrasounds: One ultrasound got coded wrong as “fertility.” It was kicked back. I called billing, had them recode it as prenatal, and then it got shared. Took three phone calls. Not fun, but it worked.
  • Sprained ankle: Urgent care, x-rays, brace. We asked for the “cash price” up front. Big discount. Then Solidarity shared most of it after re-pricing. I learned to always ask for the cash price. Always.
  • Therapy: They shared a set number of counseling visits. Mine were telehealth. Easy to book. Clear rules. When I reached the visit cap, sharing stopped. Straightforward.

Things they wouldn’t share

  • Birth control, IVF, or sterilization. This is part of why we picked it, so no shock there.
  • Some “wellness” extras. Gym stuff was on me. Fine.

What felt great

  • Costs were lower each month than an ACA plan for us.
  • Values matched ours. I didn’t feel weird paying for things I can’t support.
  • They reimbursed part of our NFP class. That felt… seen.

What drove me a little nuts

  • Claims moved slow. Like, months slow. I had to call, email, and nudge.
  • I became the middle person. Me, the clinic, and the share. Lots of back-and-forth.
  • I had to keep savings for that AUA. Plus any delays. Not a bad habit, but still.

Would I use it again? With eyes open, yes. But I’d warn a friend about the follow-up work.

Story Two: My employer plan at a Catholic school (Christian Brothers Services)

When I worked part-time at a Catholic school, my health plan ran through Christian Brothers Services. It used a big national network (ours linked through Aetna). This one is actual insurance.

Day to day felt easy

  • I had a normal ID card. Doctors recognized it.
  • $25 copay for my primary care visits. $50 for urgent care. Predictable.
  • A $1,000 deductible. After that, coinsurance kicked in. Nothing odd.

What they covered for me

  • Post-baby care: Lactation consults were covered. Not all breast pump models, but one decent option was paid.
  • MRI for a sports injury: Needed prior auth. Annoying, but fast. Two business days.
  • Therapy: Weekly for a stretch. I paid a copay. Smooth.

What they excluded by policy

  • No birth control. No IVF. No sterilization. This is standard for Catholic employer plans.
  • I asked about vasectomy coverage for my spouse. Not covered. At least they were clear.
  • Fertility care like NaPro had some coverage. But it needed the right diagnosis codes. We asked before we booked anything.

Customer service

Surprisingly kind. No long hold times for me. They explained rules in plain terms. I called twice about a prior auth and left both calls calm. That’s rare.

Would I stay on it? Yes, if I worked there. It just worked. I didn’t have to be the bill referee.

So… which one fits who?

Here’s my real-world split, based on how it felt, not a brochure.

  • Pick a Catholic health share if:

    • You want lower monthly costs.
    • You want your dollars aligned with Church teaching.
    • You can handle calling billing offices and waiting on claims.
    • You keep a cash cushion for your AUA and any timing gaps.

  • Pick a Catholic employer plan if:

    • You want easy network access and set copays.
    • You like less paperwork and fewer phone calls.
    • You agree with the moral exclusions and know the rules.
    • You get employer help with premiums. That part matters.

  • Skip both and go ACA if:

    • You need coverage for birth control, IVF, or procedures not allowed by Catholic plans.
    • You qualify for big subsidies. Sometimes ACA beats everything on total cost.

That said, some readers land on the opposite end of the spectrum—wanting resources that embrace a more secular, sexually open lifestyle. If you’re curious about how modern, no-strings-attached hookup platforms work, the in-depth review at SnapBang walks you through membership costs, privacy safeguards, and real-user tips so you can decide whether that kind of liberated approach to adult connections fits your own comfort level. For those who travel through the Mountain West and wonder how on-demand companionship works in smaller cities, a quick primer on the Casper, Wyoming scene can be worth a glance—Listcrawler Casper guide breaks down current ad etiquette, safety red flags, and what to budget before you text a provider, giving you practical intel for lining up a stress-free meetup.

You know what? Both paths can work. They just ask different things from you.

What I wish I knew on day one

  • Call and ask the cash price before care. Even for imaging and labs. I saved hundreds.
  • Get bills itemized. Coding errors are common. One code can change everything.
  • Ask, “Is this in-network?” Don’t guess. Networks change.
  • Keep a folder (paper or digital). EOBs, receipts, notes. You’ll thank yourself later.
  • Read the sharing/plan guidelines. Not the whole thing at once. A page a night. Circle stuff.
  • Set aside your AUA or deductible. Out of sight, out of mind, but still there.

Faith, money, and peace of mind

I’ll be honest. Values mattered to us. I felt better paying into a system that matched what we believe about life and care. That peace has a price, though. Sometimes it’s more phone time. Sometimes it’s a rule you don’t love. Sometimes it’s both.

Would I recommend “Catholic health insurance”? Yes—with context:

  • The health share gave us lower monthly costs and strong conscience peace, but it needed hustle and patience.
  • The employer plan was simple and steady, with clear Catholic limits.

If you want my bottom line: pick the setup you’ll actually manage on a busy Tuesday. Because real life is work, kids, a sprained ankle, and a bill that arrives right before dinner. The right plan is the one you can carry without losing your cool.

And keep snacks in the car. Trust me on that one.

More posts